Contrary to new 'natural meaning' law, Knoxville judge deems female a 'husband'

A Knox County judge appears to have thumbed his nose at state legislators who hoped to define "natural and ordinary" meanings to state laws, even as they were passing the statute.

The timeline is of interest here, as is an understanding of a certain circularity regarding this specific case. The divorce and child custody battle of Knoxville residents Sabrina and Erica Witt, you may recall, triggered the involvement of the Family Action Council of Tennessee's David Fowler in the development of a bill that would specifically define the words 'husband' and 'wife' to their traditional 'male' and 'female' interpretations. Before the LGBT Erasure bill was presented (the one that Governor Haslam signed last week), an earlier version specifically identified the words 'husband' and 'wife' for definition; that one was denounced so roundly that legislators abandoned it in favor of the vaguely worded, "sneaky" erasure bill.

In the meantime, the divorce and child custody case of the Witts carried on. Last fall, Judge Greg McMillan refused to acknowledge Erica Witt as the co-parent of a daughter born to Sabrina Witt — her wife at the time of the child's birth. Fifty-three Republican state legislators, as well as David Fowler, attempted to intervene in the case and, though, Judge McMillan refused their attempt to step in, he essentially agreed with them.

Fast-forward to Spring 2017. That very same Judge Greg McMillan effectively reversed his own decision when he chose to identify Erica Witt as a co-parent — specifically, the 'husband' under state law — of Sabrina Witt as it regards the parentage of their child. Last month, in denying the legislator's attempt to intervene, McMillan acknowledged the separation of legislative and judicial power that the "natural and ordinary meaning" bill attempts to circumnavigate.

Though his decision came before the LGBT Erasure bill was signed by the governor and put into place, it brings to light the complexity of the situation for all of us, in that the selectivity of which statute applies to LGBT Tennesseans — whether its vague language such as (ironically) the "natural and ordinary" meaning law, or the specific interpretive direction as suggested by Attorney General Slatery — lies in the hands of each individual judge.




The Perfect Jean

Disclaimer: This product has been tested and reviewed by our writer and any views or opinions are their own. Please note there are affiliate links and at no additional cost to you, we may earn a commission if you make a purchase.

I don’t know what it is with men’s jeans that make it so difficult to find the right pair. It takes time to go through all these denim brands and try styles like straight-legged, boot-cut, and then the disco favorite, flared jeans. Thanks to popular metal bands back in the day, acid-washed and stone-washed jeans were a thing–pair those with a biker jacket and some big hair, and you were set.

Keep readingShow less
Photo by Margo Amala on Unsplash

The Best Cannabis Edibles for 2023

Disclaimer: Please note there are affiliate links and at no additional cost to you, we may earn a commission if you make a purchase.

I think we’ve all been there back in the day when we smoked our first joint, and then some, (sorry mom)–hacking, coughing, and choking on the herbaceous weed. Nowadays, there are several products on the market that produces the same effects but without a sore throat like the popular cannabis edibles.

Keep readingShow less
a person holding a padlock in front of a window

As an LGBTQ+ patient, you should be able to expect the same high-quality care provided to all patients. Unfortunately, this doesn’t necessarily always prove to be the case. There remains a notoriously significant disparity in healthcare outcomes for LGBTQ+ patients, often related to issues with discrimination among providers.

Even when you find a good physician, this doesn’t mean that everyone interacting with your healthcare information will be as respectful or responsible. It is, therefore, important to be vigilant about how your data is handled. You have a right to privacy just as you have an expectation of fair treatment.

Keep readingShow less