Local gay-marriage advocates are heartened by yesterday’s federal-court decision in two separate cases declaring parts of the 1995 Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) unconstitutional, but they fear that portions of the ruling may lead to further confusion in the short term.

“We’re cautiously optimistic,” says Chris Sanders, chair of the Tennessee Equality Project’s Nashville committee. “The idea that DOMA violates the equal-protection clause of the constitution is something that marriage advocates have been saying for a long time, and it’s nice to hear a court say it as well. But the 10th Amendment part of the ruling that says states are sovereign over issues means that this will continue to play out.”

The court held that the portion of the statute barring federal legal protections to legally married same-sex couples violates states’ rights to define marriage, and also violates the equal-protection clause by treating married same-sex couples differently than their heterosexual counterparts. Prior to DOMA’s passage, the federal government always recognized the states’ right to define marriage.

The cases were brought by the Massachusetts attorney general and Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders.

In related news, the Respect for Marriage Act is currently pending in the U.S. House of Representatives. It would repeal DOMA and respect state marriages by providing federal protections for married same-sex couples. Specifically, once the federal government recognizes the marriage of a same-sex couple, it would continue to recognize that marriage even if the couple moved to another state that would not have allowed the couple to marry in the first place.

“[The] decision is an important step forward for marriage for same-sex couples,” said James Esseks, Director of the ACLU Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Project. “There are thousands of same-sex couples lawfully married in the five states and Washington, DC, that currently allow them the freedom to marry. Today’s ruling recognizes that the federal government has literally no justification for refusing to respect those marriages.”

For his part, Sanders added that the best-case scenario locally would be for this issue to continue on to the U.S. Supreme Court, which has at least one other major case headed its way with the discrimination challenge to California’s Proposition 8.

“If the statute is finally struck down, then we’d have a situation in Tennessee where we would have to look at whether or not marriages performed out of state are going to be legal here,” Sanders said. “It looks like DOMA is finally getting the type of challenges that are going to bring it down.”

Photo courtesy of Red Bull

Red Bull Unlocked Nashville


Keep reading Show less
Photo courtesy of Rumble Boxing Gulch Nashville

Rumble Boxing Gulch, Nashville


Keep reading Show less

Post-Covid travel planning

Who would have thought that we would have to get through a pandemic in order to appreciate the small things we have, such as the ability to simply pack our bags and hit the road?

For two years, there’s been nothing left for us travel junkies to do but sit at home and try to find new destinations that we will conquer once we defeat what appears to be the biggest villain of the 21st century. But once that happens, hold your bags tight because we will be up for some of the most interesting travel experiences. Take a look at some ideas for your post-COVID traveling plans:

Keep reading Show less